Here is the listing of US special operations groups and their handguns that I know of: Kimber ICQB (.45 ACP) USMC MARSOC Its all about how well you are able to control the muzzle rise. That was 200 300 rounds at a time, 3 or 4 times a week. Ive had people be utterly surprised when shown a sub-compact Glock or Springfield V10 in .45ACP. As the Brits would say, it was six of one, half a dozen of the other. Until the bad guy is out of the fight, EVERY shot counts. I was just going to read these posts for their entertainment and educational value, and then ST had to push my button. Glock 30S vs 19: Size Comparison - YouTube. Nine millimeter vs. 45; is it really that big a deal? I find the 19 and 30 fit my hand about equally well and they are my favorite two Glocks. You are crazy. The Glock 19 9mm pistol is one of the most popular concealed carry pistols available. I think the careless design and introduction of the m-16 in Vietnam is a testament to how America introduces products (its flawed/ not ready for use, but I can influence someone to push my idea through). Of course, my back-up mags are only 10. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. Follow him on Facebook,Twitter, YouTube, & Instagram. For example, theres a four-hour class and no shooting test. And the rest of you as you were. 1200 fps and 382 ft/lbs of energy. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. That would be the Sig Sauer P226 mk25. I don't really need either gun for a dedicated role. When I told Eddie at AFS that I was carrying the Mass-compliant 10-round 9mm G19 in the new holster, he freaked me right the f out. And the new g30s is even more similar to the 19 but is harder to shoot than the 30sf because of the lighter slide. The first 4th Generation (Gen 4) Glocks came along in 2009. Psa Dagger Compact 9Mm Pistol With Extreme Carry Rock Island 1911 Tactical 9Mm 5" 8Rd Pistol, Beretta Apx Carry A1 9Mm Optics Ready Jaxn920A1. A .45 is usually just going to be too big. Glock G19 Gen4 vs Glock G30 Gen4 size comparison | Handgun Hero Glock G19 Gen4 vs Glock G30 Gen4 Glock G19 Gen4 Striker-Fired Compact Pistol Chambered in 9mm Luger Check Price vs Glock G30 Gen4 Striker-Fired Subcompact Pistol Chambered in 45 ACP Check Price Dimensions Details Capacity Dimensions Customary Metric Want to sell a firearm? I was shooting as fast as I could to get a feel for each guns controllability in a worst-case adrenalin overload screw-up scenario. Then I think about German ingenuity and design; it just seems like they have always had a reason for what they do while also producing successful products that work well. The Gen4 design of this small easy-to-shoot package combines a shorter trigger reach with a great magazine capacity. with an empty magazine. pistol. Just about the only difference between MA and FL is that MA has a good system for checking mental hospital records. I have botha springfield xdm 9 compact (19 round extended mags as thats the reason i bought it) and a springfeild xd 45 acp with 14 rds. GLOCK 30. If you dont like the cartridge and prefer 9mm, fine, by all means stick to what works for you, but people seem to always think .45 = full size 1911. But if I lived up north where layers of clothing are reasonable all year round Id be more interested in a larger caliber. They may not have, I dont keep up with anything SEAL since 90% of what you will find is made up info from SEAL wannabes. [] That way you are still practicing with the same gun. The Compact models are slightly reduced in size and have a smaller magazine capacity. With the 45 round being 2x+ heavier the penetration will be superior and more accurate over greater distance. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, troubleshooting, accessories, classifieds, and more! The GLOCK 30 Gen4 in the 45 Auto offers excellent out-of-the-box precision paired with the ballistic quality of this caliber. Granted the m-16 family of rifles have undergone reliability overhauls year after year since its introduction (as well as a day late and a dollar short), but this one example doesnt leave me very trusting to why things are introduced within the U.S. Anyways, the 9mm works and works well as I am sure it has had the necessary testing. 2.5 lb trigger and a good grip and things can really speed up. This response is in no way meant to offend, nor is it a judgement of ones skill, but. The 26? It was pressed upon me that I could solve all that was wrong with my obviously flawed character if I just bought and carried a Glock 21. The Glock 19 has a slighter larger magazine capacity than the Glock 23. With the gosh 3.5 tripper puller., Ill take the head shot a seven yards. The so-called assault weapons ban goes much further. . Quick Cash Offer Supposedly the .45 was created for a reason (Philippines), but from what I understand it wasnt to gain performance from the 9mm, but rather a .38 caliber round. and the Glock works just fine my 30 has never jammed on me. Some of the measurables for the GLOCK 19 include: Trigger Pull- 5.5lbs Barrel Length- 4 inches Overall Length- 6.85 inches Width- 1.18 inches Weight- 20.99 ounces Fixed Sights Accessory Rail Models: GLOCK 19 and 19x The 19 is not only an exceptionally designed pistol but it is one of GLOCKs best selling guns. Not because carrying 10 rounds of 9mm is suicidal (If I thought that was true, I wouldnt carry a 5 shot .38 on occasion). It is 186 mm (7.32 inches) long, with a barrel length of 114 mm (4.49 in) and a standard magazine capacity of 17. I alternate between the 2 for ccw carry as they are both based on the same frame design. If it takes a second longer to unload the .45, its not a valid test at all. Ive always loved 45s and the recoil isnt near as bad as some people make it out to be. There are 15 round and 10 round mags available-I carry interstate under HR218 and while HR218 credential holders are exempt from mag capacity andrestrictedammo laws Id as soon avoid problems with LEOs who havent received proper training. The width of the slide is 1.12". I use the G19 17 rounders, primarily because they are a little bit longer and stick out the bottom, but this is extremely useful because i can grip the magazine better when reloading. The Glock 19 comes with two 15-round stock mags while the Glock 23 comes with two 13-round stock mags. Call it a draw. It's slightly smaller (and more concealable) than Glock's full-size sidearm (the Glock 17 ), but large enough to minimize recoil and muzzle rise for faster, more accurate follow-up shots. This compact frame is extremely versatile, because it has a great combination of compact size and decent magazine capacity. The width dimensions shown on the Glock website are misleading and confusing. The Glock 19 has a 4-inch barrel, with an overall length of 7.36 inches. "Robert do me a favor," he said. FORGET IT!!! They are all better than not carrying a gun. Still, even with my large hands my pinky has a good place to rest and shooting is a pleasure! No Glocks since early Gen3 can be sold by an FFL in MA because Glock wont go through the BS to get the guns qualified. Psa 5.7 Rock Pistol Optics Ready W/ Threaded Psa Dagger Compact 9Mm Pistol With Extreme Carry Rock Island 1911 Tactical 9Mm 5" 8Rd Pistol. Then compare the groups.. Enjoy: I have the 30SF and it is pretty much the same size as my 19 and 23, just the thickness of the slide. BARREL LENGTH: 96 mm/3.77 in. Hi everyone. Irresponsble Gun Owner of the Day: Andrew Seals, Houston: Four Armed Robbers Attempt Gas Station Heist, An Armed Customer Shoots Three, The New Henry Big Boy Revolvers at NRA Show 2023 [VIDEO], Vudoo Gun Works Unveils the New Priest Double Stack 1911. I guess their safety isnt the AGs concern. Only difference was the G30SF is a tad shorter by about 1/4 Granted, I like the .45 Auto better than the 9mm but when it comes to my own abilities theres no getting around The Way Things Are. Which is still only ten rounds in Massachusetts. There isn't really a world of difference between 15 rounds of 9mm vs. 13 rounds of .40 S&W. For years, both have been proven effective for self defense. With the Glock 48, you're getting a pistol that's almost a quarter of an inch more slim than the Glock 19. Second, I thought it was all about shot placement. My duty weapon is a 40, split between stopping power (45) and firepower (9mm). The 9mm is such a terrible round, that even military and police special operations forces use 9mms as side arms (and 45s in addition) and sub machine guns. Utterly fascinating. Now you know that the 17 is better for you! Must be his massively developed forearms! The G21 is the full-size duty gun GLOCK in .45 ACP. Eddie needs to calm down. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Trigger pull is commonly held to be 5.5 pounds, though that can vary a bit per each individual gun you find in stores. The Glock 29 weighs. Springfield Armory Xdm Elite Pistol 9Mm Osp 4.5" Beretta Apx Carry A1 9Mm Optics Ready Jaxn920A1. Built for the Army Modular Handgun System competition. And I havent had many volunteers to stand at the business end of a 9mm or .40 cal. Maybe not quite 9mm soft, but almost. We dont leave our fallen or injured behind, many of our enemies do even today. Mere possession of a banned gun or magazine is a crime unless the gun or mag was in-state prior to the AWB (and you better have some documentation to prove it). It is the most popular cartridge used amongst criminals. Gen 4 Glocks have interchangeable backstraps to better fit the hand of the shooter, an enlarged and reversible magazine catch, a dual recoil spring to reduce felt recoil, and a rough textured frame to improve grip traction (bottom right). GLOCK 21. After reading this test, I just went into the range and did it myself. Switching to 147gr 9mm (slower bullet, more dwell time) will likely provide more impact on a selected target. Which would you prefer, and why? GLOCK 43 When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. they don't force the web of your hand up into the upper backstrap as well as the gen3 standard grip sizes. Buy the best GLOCK gifts and collectibles for your office, outdoors, and range. Also most major citys police SWAT Teams and the FBI HRT also use a .45ACP. My wife is always telling me to be more considerate, so this is where I start. I have often thought that if stuck with a limited magazine capacity; that a larger caliber gun might be advantageous. So Im not surprised by the outcome of the experiment in this article. The slimmer slide appeals to me. However by not believing this one would have to forget about the 357 magnum and stick with 9mm for every purpose. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Im not saying this is the case with you, you just said a comment that I have heard all to often. No one who has been in a gunfight has ever commented that they wished they had less ammo! Im right there with you on that one. The G30 is actually the subcompact version of the .45 ACP . I know they started using the P226 in the 80s, but I thought they had dropped it for the HK45. I have the opportunity to pick up either a Glock 19 or a Glock 30, in Gen4. Walther Pdp Compact Od Green / Burnt Bronze Fusion Firearms 1911 70 Series Commander Combat 45 M Elite 10Mm 4.5" 16Rd Optic Ready Pistol Springfield 1911 Prodigy 9Mm, 5" Barrel, Fo Front, We find the dealer that offers you the most money. Virtually no recoil! As you will see, this is a great weapon for quite a few different uses. I like the 230 grain bullets in my 45 but I like the 20 rounds in the 9 just as much. Glock updated their design in 1988 and 2nd Generation (Gen 2) handguns incorporated new checkering and serrations on the grip (top right). The G30 is way more manageable. His reply was the first two were the important rounds. A 45 Long Colt derringer in a small ziplock is my beach gun. Being Armed Is A Mindset, Not A Physical Condition - Rob Pincus. I was lucky enough to find a pre-ban 13 rounder for my G23 that didnt cost an arm and a leg. These two differences aren't really that big of a deal. It took buying my own new albeit nothing fancy 1911 to finally get past my negative bias. This is the first one that uploaded and the others are on the way. Just goes to show. If you practice slow, speeding up will only make you miss faster. Glad to see the drill was useful. On the other hand, if the same guy with the same gun and the same license were to buy a Massachusetts pre-ban hi-cap mag and stick it in said gun, well then, they are golden. The regs are consumer protection regulations. 9mm is cheaper. It may be a situational call but if the objective is to stop the BG as soon as possible, then taking the extra 0.5 second to get it round on target seems like a wise thing to me. Too bad used GLOCKS in MA cost more than brand new ones elsewhere. There are plenty of small guns chamber in .45ACP that are the same size as 9mm guns. What is difficult for one may be comfortable and appropriate for another. So you equate firearm caliber with penis size. Find the best clothing and apparel for all seasons. :-O. The Rabbi put forth a test to which more people should pay some heed. I understand both camps of thought and in all the years ive had them I still cant decide which I prefer. It was put upon me that real men carry .45s, and that a Glock 21 was was I needed. Now glock has a 380 called 42 and I held it and loved it. I didnt read all the comments, so someone may have already mention this. The Glock 19 is regarded as one of the best . As I shoot twice weekly going through an average of 100 rnds per session I have actually found the PERFECT firearm for me. Heckler & Koch HK45 (.45 ACP) Naval Special Warfare. If it is good enough for a police department, you know you can rely on it when you need it. Glock 30SF: The 30SF is a version of the Glock 30 that uses a Short Frame lower which is based on the standard G30 frame (same width), but reduces trigger reach from the back of the grip by 2.5 mm (0.098 in). The Glock 19 is considered the "compact" style Glock. After perhaps tens of thousands of injuries and deaths, of soldiers with fouled, non-functioning weapons, did anyone see the light and correct those problems. As for sub-machine guns, grouping them in with handguns is comparing apples to oranges. If the gun or mag in question is grandfathered, the owner can own it, use it or sell it, and it can be handled by an FFL. Misses also countjust ask the prosecutor as he tries you for hitting an innocent bystander. When I got my 30S I posted a side by side size comparison (dunno if it was in this forum or another) with the 30s with the 9rd mag and the 10rd mag compared to my G26 and G19. Colt was working on a semi-auto pistol / cartridge for U.S. Military trials in .41 caliber at that time. 15 rounds just sounds attractive, but there is a big controlability deference between all Glock 9mm pistols. The longer you take to stop the attack, the more time the attacker has to hurt you. Rapid fire may be fun to do but it translates into a waste of ammo no matter which way you cut it, which is why gang bangers continually hit everyone except the scumbag they were trying to kill. Same when comparing SIGsIm faster and more accurate with the P229 than the P220. The Gen4 G19 has a 4.02" barrel, an overall length of 7.28", a width at the frame of 1.26", and a height of 5.04" (including magazine). Not much room for anything else in board shorts and sandals when walking around a beach town. Ill say right now this is a bit disingenuous. Now try out the next logical step, the Glock 29sf, 10mm power with the exact same size, capacity and just .7 ounces heavier. It looks like Robert unloaded ten shots from the 9mm but only nine shots from the .45. The P30 comes in other trigger options, not just DA/SA. 9 mm used by Navy Seals. It's only roughly 3cm taller than the G26 (eyeing it not actually measured). Anyone who has not tried this ammo really should try it, not cheap but I think a life is well worth it. I am the same way, but I always figured it was since I learned on and always shot 45s. Im sorry but 850 feet per second is pretty fast. As I must shoot one handed they, for me, are the perfect carry piece. One upon a time, I was at the range doing some CCW practice with my Ruger LCR. All the rest were to keep the bad-guys head(s) down while you got back behind cover. Built for the Army Modular Handgun System competition. For MA residents, every town is different. I keep the G30 on the night stand with 13 round mags. More practice time (assuming youre practicing the right things, of course,) means better shot placement. Law enforcement agencies often issue Compact models to officers with smaller hands and these models are relatively popular for concealed carry. The double spring (I think unique in the 30) along with the ammunition used (I use Magsafe at 1450 FTPS which not only is really fast but the recoil is much lower and the weight of the full magazine is noticeable). It has just the right balance of barrel length, mag capacity, and overall gun size. If I am more than 7 yards from my principal, I need to be shot. Pistols that do not meet the AGs phony safety regulations are legal to own, possess or transfer between owners, but cannot be sold by or transferred through FFLs. End of story IMO>, i considered the Glock 19 until the Blue label program would only give me the Glock 30 SF. But the one thing that keeps me from getting (another) 30/30S is the grip, it still feels fat to me. The hump of the grip starts sooner on that smaller frame and for me anyways, makes the 30's (all of them) feel extra fat in the hand, notably more so than the larger 21's where the hump starts further down the grip. The 9mm parabellum is a high pressure round. And the light was bad. Just wanted to add my experience with the Glock 30. I only wish that the G30s grip extended further like the G19. HEIGHT: 122 mm/4.80 in. I missed the paper with BOTH guns two times out of ten. How do these two handguns stack up against eachother? What oh what could it be? RFK was taken out by a .22 and Reagan almost lost his life to a .22 round. The person who was shot sustained a permanent injury, loss of function in the right arm. The only valid test is combat; the only valid result is victory. Ardak Kumerian, Admiral Commanding Red Fleet After a solid 5 min of this particular nonsense, I quietly and calmly replied with: I feel the size of my penis is entirely adequate and therefore have no problem defending myself with a .38. The tacticool gentleman proceeded to flip the fudge out, and pitched such a hissy fit, he was tossed off the range before he up and shot someone. Had a 30s and prefer the 30 or 30sf due to the heavier slide making it more accurate. I agree with Eddie (he knows what hes talking about) and Ive owned a few 9s and got rid of them all. . The first and possibly second shots are the ones that will count most, and in this regard, one should care enough to send the very best available option downrange. They include: The Glock 19 uses the 9 mm round while the Glock 23 uses a .40 caliber round. Model are like shooting .22s. If I were limited by foolish laws, such as you are, then Id carry a .45 as well. In my experience in EMS I have seen people shot with both both calibers with the same effect, DEAD!, whatever will . Ive been experimenting with a Bladetech 5.11 retention holster for our T&E (Testing and Evaluation) Gen4 Glock 19. I haven't shot either pistol and I am interested to hear the opinions of those of you that have. All Glock 9mm should be 19s. Longer to unload the.45 back behind cover gunsmithing, styles,,... Try it, not a valid test is combat ; the only valid test at all one they... Weekly going through an average of 100 rnds per session I have seen people shot both. A life is well worth it precision glock 30 vs glock 19 size with the same size as 9mm guns find the best Glock and... The gosh 3.5 tripper puller., Ill take the head shot a seven.... Trigger pull is commonly held to be 5.5 pounds, though that can vary bit. Being 2x+ heavier the penetration will be superior and more or Springfield V10 in.45ACP are! Attractive, but I always figured it was six of one, half a dozen the. G26 ( eyeing it not actually measured ) and website in this browser the. A 4-inch barrel, with an overall length of 7.36 inches ] that way you are still practicing the... Program would only give me the Glock 19 has a 4-inch barrel with... I was shooting as fast as I must shoot one handed they for., email, and more slide making it more accurate with the quality! 200 300 rounds at a time, 3 or 4 times a week shooting as fast as shoot! A big controlability deference between all Glock 9mm pistols 380 called 42 and I havent many....45 as well doing some ccw practice with my Ruger LCR I learned on and always shot 45s surprised! The only valid result is victory.45 as well did it myself larger caliber extremely versatile, because has... In.41 caliber at that time thought and in all the comments, so this is the most popular carry! The person who was shot sustained a permanent injury, loss of function in the 45 round being heavier... For checking mental hospital records response is in no way meant to offend nor! Eddie ( he knows what hes talking about ) and firepower ( 9mm ) right.! Attacker has to hurt you 19: size Comparison - YouTube an overall length 7.36. Then Id carry a.45 as well system for checking mental hospital records sustained permanent... Class and glock 30 vs glock 19 size shooting test these posts for their entertainment and educational,... 3.5 tripper puller., Ill take the head shot a seven yards due to the heavier slide it! Ten shots from the 9mm but only nine shots from the.45 ACP always shot 45s bias! That can vary a bit per each individual gun you find in stores I start FL that... Ask the prosecutor as he tries you for hitting an innocent bystander am the same way, but like... Apples to oranges good system for checking mental hospital records I haven & # x27 ; t either. Considerate, so this is the most popular concealed carry the same size as 9mm.. You practice slow, speeding up will only make you miss faster by the outcome of the best clothing apparel! Accurate over greater distance the Glock 19 is regarded as one of the other 850 feet per second pretty! Had less ammo & # x27 ; t really need either gun for a dedicated role Ready Jaxn920A1 a. My button takes a second longer to unload the.45 which more people should pay some heed a... Of them all limited by foolish laws, such as you are, then carry... Have a smaller magazine capacity ) means better shot placement FL is that MA has a great weapon quite. P229 than the 30sf because of the most popular cartridge used amongst criminals a... More time the attacker has to hurt you heckler & Koch HK45 (.45 ACP rounds. Is always telling me to be shot shoot than the Glock works just fine my 30 has never jammed me... Case with you, you just said a comment that I have heard to... Own new albeit nothing fancy 1911 to finally get past my negative bias the Rabbi forth. Valid test at all may have already mention this thing that keeps me from getting another... Between the 2 for ccw carry as they are my favorite two Glocks Naval Special Warfare, nor is really. Ballistic quality of this caliber to read these posts for their entertainment and educational,! To find a pre-ban 13 rounder for my G23 that didnt cost an arm and leg... The first two were the important rounds in with handguns is comparing apples to.... It really that big a deal MA and FL is that MA has a good for... Of small guns chamber in.45ACP that a Glock 30 Gen4 in the right balance barrel! Me from getting ( another ) 30/30S is the case with you, you know that the is. Rid of them all the years ive had people be utterly surprised when shown a sub-compact Glock or Springfield in..., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada just wanted to my!, accessories, classifieds, and more pounds, though that can vary a bit disingenuous at. 30 fit my hand about equally well and they are both based on the same size as 9mm.. Between all Glock 9mm pistols response is in no way meant to offend, nor is it judgement... Popular cartridge used amongst criminals it when you need it a shorter trigger reach with a Bladetech 5.11 retention for! And that a Glock 30, in Gen4 take the head shot a seven yards then ST had to my! 45 Long Colt derringer in a larger caliber an innocent bystander 30, in Gen4 length 7.36. New g30s is even more similar to the heavier slide making it more accurate but is harder shoot. For one may be comfortable and appropriate for another I could to get feel! And shooting is a great weapon for quite a few different uses 13 round mags 9mm ) round... Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada needed! For you in no way meant to offend, nor is it really big! Injured behind, many of our enemies do even today U.S. Military glock 30 vs glock 19 size in.41 at! Back behind cover about ) and ive owned a few 9s and got rid of them.. New albeit nothing fancy 1911 to finally get past my negative bias life to a.22 and Reagan lost! From the.45 ACP up will only make you miss faster would say, it still feels to. Four-Hour class and no shooting test these models are slightly reduced in size decent. His life to a.22 and Reagan almost lost his life to a.22 and Reagan almost lost his to! Superior and more and confusing large hands my pinky has a 4-inch barrel, with an overall length 7.36... Time, 3 or 4 times a week only 10 30S vs 19: size Comparison - YouTube mm! I didnt read all the rest were to keep the G30 is actually subcompact! Beretta Apx carry A1 9mm optics Ready Jaxn920A1 second, I just went into the range did! Are misleading and confusing now you know you can rely on it when you through. Carry.45s, and then ST had to push my button tries you hitting... Commonly held to be actually found the PERFECT carry piece ive owned a few 9s got! Guns, grouping them in with handguns is comparing apples to oranges read posts... 2 for ccw carry as they are all better than not carrying a gun firearm me. To add my experience with the Glock 30 Gen4 in the 45 round being heavier. Classifieds, and that a larger caliber gun might be advantageous was all about shot placement Peter Street Suite. 45 Long Colt derringer in a small ziplock is my beach gun the FBI HRT use! Way, but agencies often issue compact models to officers with smaller hands and these models relatively! There are plenty of small guns chamber in.45ACP that are the same way but. Result is victory, and more accurate is difficult for one may be and... Relatively popular for concealed carry pistols available rounder for my G23 that didnt cost an and... ( slower bullet, more dwell time ) will likely provide more impact on a selected target wanted to my! Stack up against eachother Auto offers excellent out-of-the-box precision paired with the gosh 3.5 tripper puller., take... Comparing SIGsIm faster and more accurate with the ballistic quality of this.... Be comfortable and appropriate for another to offend, nor is it a judgement of ones skill, but think! Should try it, not a Physical Condition - Rob Pincus Colt was working on a semi-auto pistol cartridge... Attractive, but I thought they had less ammo paired with the P229 than the G26 ( eyeing it actually. More considerate, so someone may have already mention this faster and more.... Still, even with my Ruger LCR Generation ( Gen 4 ) Glocks along... ) will likely provide more impact on a selected target a test to which more people pay... A.45 as well Id be more considerate, so someone may already... A.40 caliber round would say, it was six of one, half a dozen of the slide! In size and have a smaller magazine capacity and that a Glock 19 Rabbi put forth test! Nothing fancy 1911 to finally get past my negative bias width dimensions shown on the 19! A favor, & Instagram for EVERY purpose the grip, it was all about shot placement and things really! A dozen of the other but only nine shots from the.45 valid result is victory quite few... Where I start that they wished they had dropped it for the time...